Sunday, December 7, 2008

Taarein Zameen Par

"Har ek ungli pakad kar lagien usko lamba bananein mein", this dialogue from TZP really struck me while watching the movie. I found it to be so relevant when i reflect on our education system. Does the beggar child at the traffic light need to know how to solve sums on integration and derivatives? Do the little kids who are now homeless because of the Sardar Sarovar Dam on the Narmada need to learn the kinetics of chemical reactions? We are so busy focusing on what other people's children are doing that parents forget that they are destroying their own child's individuality. If your son or daughter loves to play outside all day long, climbing trees and scaling the compound walls, do we think anymore that he will make an amazing mountaineer some day?
What i feel parents should understand is that becoming an engineer, doctor, ca or for that matter even graduating isn't everything. Classrooms are just not for everyone. Rather than making machines out of every single child why can't we let children grow up as individuals. Also taking into account the trials and tribulations of under privileged youngsters why can't we equip them with the skills necessary to survive, teach them something relevant so that they are able to stand on their own two feet and earn a livelihood. teach them how to weave or make handicrafts, repair small appliances or a skill like carpentry. They do not really need to know what is 2 to the power 5 or what happens when light passes through a prism.
The same problem comes to light when I see adults interacting with children who have a learning disorders or similar problems. What is 5 for normal people is usually as hard as 10 for these children but we still expect them to cope up. Why not encourage drawing or music which these children might be good at. Make them computer literate so that they can apply themselves easily doing data entries or other relatively easier things and gradually keep on adding more skills with increasing level of complexity and side by side honing their previous skills. They will get a sense of achievement which is so satisfying which you and I know so very well. I speak about this as this kind of an exercise has worked wonders with my own sister who is a slow learner. But the pride I see on her face when she types a letter, teaches my mother to write an email, is by far unparalleled. The joy she derives from working part time in small IT firm and the confidence she has gained by dealing with the world as an independent being is far more satisfying and joyous to watch. These little self experiences do not seem so trivial when you put them in perspective.
I am not at all saying that scrap education entirely. Basic level of literacy should be achieved, but it need not be done in 3 languages (English, Hindi and Marathi/Gujarati/Tamil etc), 10+2+3 or many more years. It should be done with keeping in mind that education should liberate people and not burden them with expectations of the world. We are born as individuals, but why not remain as individuals? Remember, people do not come off a production line, but rather they are custom made masterpieces which fulfill specific and equally important duties, however significant those activities may seem to you or me.

2 comments:

Ketki Joshi said...

Awsome!!!
N congrats for the very first post of urs on d blog...
this is something that must be thought about. new n fresh perspective!

Juz would like to add up something dat i found relevant to ur topic:
Carl Gustav once said,
"If there is anything that we wish to change in the child, we should first examine it and see whether it is not something that could better be changed in ourselves"
As u have mentioned few lines about children at play, I feel playing is their most serious-minded activity...
So the art of dealing wit children is knowing "what not to say"

N last but not the least, how can I forget Ameera?
I completely agree that these ways have worked wonders. she is amazing.

So lookin forward to many thought provoking topics on ur blog...
Keep up the good work.
Love,
Ketki.

Merup Kapadia said...

a very nice thought which i agree to and you have put it across in a manner that you naturally feel about, i mean there is no garnishing or some high fundoo words used which looks artificial, pls continue putting across your thoughts on same lines and congrats for initiating this blog as in todays world, we rarely get time to express our thoughts freely.
And i am looking forward to read some more from you...
Kudos !!!